manton
manton

A core tension between AI skeptics and AI proponents is whether training data is theft or fair use. You can see it in the loaded words that people choose to use. Almost impossible to find compromise or nuance in debates when we all start at such far apart extremes. Sad, really.

|
…
Embed
drwalt
drwalt

@manton I think the nature of this conversation is deeply influenced by the combativeness our culture acquired since 2016. We should also have been able to have a rational conversation about COVID. I’m hopeful our newly elected politicians will illustrate this, if the media lets them.

|
…
Embed
manton
manton

@drwalt I think you’re exactly right. Everything has become so divisive and tribal.

|
…
Embed
JohnPhilpin
JohnPhilpin

@manton Is it tribal to think that the laws of a country should be obeyed by a corporation?

|
…
Embed
manton
manton

@JohnPhilpin Nope. I guess people disagree even on the law! In the Anthropic trial, the court ruled that training on books is fair use.

|
…
Embed
JohnPhilpin
JohnPhilpin

@manton well the law is fuzzy at times hence the process. But there are laws that are clearer … individual hackers get caught and made to pay a price … but apparently if your AI does it it’s ok .. with a ‘shrug of shoulders’ and a ‘what you gonna do’❓ … and in many ways that’s just the start.

|
…
Embed
In reply to
manton
manton

@JohnPhilpin Ultimately we’re going to need new laws that specifically address AI, because so many things are at a different scale than they were 100 years ago.

|
…
Embed
drwalt
drwalt

@manton Yes, and those laws need to be created using rational thought as if it is a polarity to be managed not a problem to be solved.

|
…
Embed
JohnPhilpin
JohnPhilpin

@manton yes AND the laws need to be upheld. If I get into trouble for hacking a system using software - that is surely a universal thing? As far as I am aware nobody even got a ‘stern letter’ over Hugging Face - and yet the govt goes after individuals for much lesser crimes.

My mind drifts back 10 or 15 years… and I only know what I have read - IMAGINE if Aaron used AI and not his brain - he might still be alive today.

|
…
Embed
ffmike
ffmike

@manton Minor correction, I think: In the Anthropic trial, the judge ruled that training on purchased books is fair use. They’re on the hook to pay out $1.5B for training on pirated books (as did every other major model). I should be getting something from the payout but it’s taking much time to settle.

|
…
Embed
manton
manton

@ffmike Right, the fine is because of the pirating. The training itself was considered significantly transformative. Of course other lawsuits are unresolved… (Great that you should get some of the money from it!)

|
…
Embed
ffmike
ffmike

@manton Sadly I think I’m going to get very little despite 40+ books in the settlement because publishers are claiming this is some right I sold as part of the original deals and I no longer have copies of decades-old contracts to check (or big enough lawyers to argue with them). But even a few bones will be nice.

|
…
Embed