manton
manton

Pacing the frontier: manton.org

|
…
Embed
rscottjones
rscottjones

@manton seems really hard to take either of these folks at face value, especially given their obvious negligence in the recent hacking episodes.

|
…
Embed
In reply to
fgtech
fgtech

@jekratz @manton Yeah, the “curing all disease” part also made me cringe. This is what I mean when I talk about how breathtakingly oversold this technology is. It’s great to have lofty goals, but let’s see some realistic ones actually achieved first.

|
…
Embed
therivertao
therivertao

@manton All the panacea/utopia language is really revealing of the mindset of these people. It’s “god-talk.” Obviously mere mortals can’t achieve these glorious goals, so we must pin our hopes on the god AI, who will take care of its children. Unbelieveable that they get away with this.

|
…
Embed
manton
manton

@apoorplayer Supposedly some Anthropic employees do believe they are creating something god-like. I’m just fascinated by the culture difference between these companies.

|
…
Embed
fgtech
fgtech

@fgtech Here is a great example of what I mean:

How Did a Heart Drug With So Much Promise Fall So Flat?

No amount of compute power or AI insight could have saved this idea to target lipoprotein A and make a drug that works. We just don’t have enough basic biological knowledge of how the body works.

|
…
Embed
manton
manton

@fgtech @jekratz It’s interesting that Dario put that in, because just a month ago he was saying people are tired of hearing “cure cancer” instead of seeing results.

|
…
Embed
fgtech
fgtech

@manton Yeah, I think you’ve heard my cynical view of what comes out of the mouths of company representatives. The simplest explanation is that they have an enormous financial incentive to talk up the capabilities of this technology. Especially now, before IPO.

I’ll be watching closely to see how the rhetoric shifts after IPO. The incentives are subtly different when you have to make quarterly numbers work. Promising the moon and then not delivering it has financial consequences.

|
…
Embed