manton
manton

Thinking about the difference between companies who use AI to make existing features better and companies who try to rethink everything. I’ve been using the iOS 18.1 beta for a while. I don’t think Apple really believes in AI the way OpenAI, Anthropic, or Microsoft do. See Microsoft’s memo from Mustafa Suleyman:

This is a new era of technology that doesn’t just “solve problems”, it’s there to support you, teach you, help you. In this sense, Copilots really are different to that last wave of the web and mobile. This is the beginning of a fundamental shift in what’s possible for all of us.

|
Embed
Progress spinner
mrwheat.bsky.social
mrwheat.bsky.social

@manton Apple always underperforms on new tech, and sometimes they never get it right. Siri and HomeKit are a classic example. Amazon opened up Alexa to third party devs and have an AWESOME ecosystem for home automation. I still can't get Siri to set the f-ing thermostat 10 years after HomeKit was released.

|
Embed
Progress spinner
mrwheat.bsky.social
mrwheat.bsky.social

@manton Apple always underperforms on new tech, and sometimes they never get it right. Siri and HomeKit are a classic example. Amazon opened up Alexa to third party devs and have an AWESOME ecosystem for home automation. I still can't get Siri to set the f-ing thermostat 10 years after HomeKit was released.

|
Embed
Progress spinner
ndw@toot.wales
ndw@toot.wales

@manton No, they're just a con. A grift. A brief, unjustifiable production of tens of millions of tons of CO2.

|
Embed
Progress spinner
bobooten.bsky.social
bobooten.bsky.social

@manton I just hope I can turn it off.

|
Embed
Progress spinner
gregmorris
gregmorris

@manton I agree. I think Apple felt pressured to put it in. Hence the “built from the ground up for AI” being a bit more ram.

I guess the pressures of shareholders and Wall St is pretty much the only pressure they feel.

|
Embed
Progress spinner
In reply to
ChrisJWilson
ChrisJWilson

@manton interesting point. Do you know the SAMR framework? I see a lot of AI that’s the first stages and sometimes makes products worse (or more resource intensive for minimal gains). Apple’s approach seems to be augmentations mostly, achieving the same ends but in a faster or whatever way. That said, some of the attempts at redefinition I’ve seen (friend) looks like “solutions” that will actually exacerbate the problem.

I’d say that MBs use looks to be mostly augmentations (like alt text for image and podcast transcripts).

|
Embed
Progress spinner
manton
manton

@ChrisJWilson I hadn't heard of SAMR. Skimming through it. To be clear, I don't think there's anything wrong with augmentation. You're right, that's Micro.blog's approach. But I also think there's a place for people trying to rethink the way things used to be.

|
Embed
Progress spinner
ChrisJWilson
ChrisJWilson

@manton yeah absolutely. I think that’s a point of SAMR, not everything has to be redefined. Augmention and modification are good too (and even just a substitution). To me it’s descriptive and poses the question “could we go further along this spectrum”.

|
Embed
Progress spinner