Unfortunately, most drugstore and high-end eyeliner are from brands that still test on animals, like Maybelline, LOreal, Revlon, MAC, Chanel, Bobbi Brown, Shiseido, Tom Ford, Clarins, Lancome, and should be avoided when looking for a cruelty-free and vegan eyeliner. L.A. Girl Jetsetter Liquid Eyeliner$8.69 $9.67 11% offThis liquid eyeliner from L.A. Girl guarantees an impressive result each and every time. Boasting a bold pigment, a fine-nib tip and long-lasting formula, it’s all you need to define your eyes like a pro. “The best eyeliner Ive tried for my greasy eyelids is Chanel Stylo Yeux. Not cheap but worth it,” one reader told us. If you prefer more luxury makeup products, this is one of the best non smudge eye liner options. I also second using eyeshadow instead of a pencil. As we get older, I think its best to make everything softly focused, instead of the harsh line of a pencil or liquid liner. I use the eyeshadow dry for a softer look, with a primer so they stay put. My favorites are Nars and Dior. For drugstore, I think NYXs mattes are identical in quality to MAC but not the satin or shimmer formulas. Ive also been impressed with the Paulas Choice eyeshadow palette for longevity, but havnt done a side by side comparison yet.