@ChrisJWilson I’m not sure deletion or deactivation are the only measures to be used when thinking about this. I have not done either of those, yet. Our schools’ PTA as well as our HOA make use of Facebook’s private groups to communicate. That’s a pretty sticky feature. But I can easily see there are fewer and fewer posts on my timeline and many people I know who used to post regularly haven’t done so in a very long time. In fact it’s down to only 5 or 6 who still post. So I’m a bit more hopeful.
@ronguest I feel like this aspect of Facebook usage (e.g., “I have to be on it because this group I deal with uses it”) is the social media version of seeing the POS system at my local Chinese restaurant that is still running on Windows XP. Everyone knows it's a bad idea and would get rid of it if they could, but can't because of these lingering dependencies.
@ronguest @petebrown @ChrisJWilson It seems like we need a collection of small companies to make (or point groups to existing) solutions to address these small, lingering dependencies (especially ones that involve small, specific groups that don’t need the network effect for getting noticed).
@smokey I believe discourse.org could be a good option for some of the closed groups. I’m in one group that moved from FB to that solution and it is working well. But... it required a specialist to set it up which many small orgs/groups wouldn’t have access to. The hosted version is far too expensive for small groups without money/funding. FB groups won because “everybody already has Facebook” and it was free. Not sure what the alternatives really are?
@ronguest I’m not familiar with Discourse—nor, for that matter, what schools and whatnot actually use FB groups for: dissemination, discussion, something else?—so I don’t know for sure that there are existing solutions.
For schools, I figured they’re already using some kind of school management software package, so adding a module that provides communication with parents seems like an obvious thing.
For neighborhoods, I thought someone could start a site to host neighborhoods, with features specific to that (whatever they might be) and support it by getting local businesses to advertise their services the old fashioned way, just instead of the Yellow Pages, and some sort of fee structure for certain features.
For other things, there’s something like groups.io, which is from the people originally behind Yahoo Groups (pre-Yahoo); my last active Yahoo Group migrated there this year; it feels like all of the good things of the original with none of the awful Yahoo “additions”…
As I said, I don’t really know the uses and what’s there, just that there seems like there’s room for some companies to develop solutions (that are less costly than $100/month!) for focused/local groups 🤞
@smokey If you've been a MAC POWER USERS podcast listener over the years, they recently moved their Facebook group over to a Discourse one on their own website. Checking it out would give you a look at the environment in action.
@rosemaryorchard Could probably speak more to the virtues of, or issues with, the software; she's community manager there. But for smaller groups, or big groups where the members prefer F R E E... Discourse is way too pricy if you go with their own bottom-tier host/support plan.
New Microblog — $5/month
We'll create and host a microblog for you at username.micro.blog or your own domain name. Includes cross-posting, pages, themes, and publishing from the web, iOS, and Mac.
New Blog + Audio + Video — $10/month
All the features of a hosted microblog plus podcast and video hosting. Upload MP3s via the web or use the companion iPhone app Wavelength to record and edit your own microcast. We'll create a podcast feed for your site.
Invite someone to Micro.blog or pay for their first year of blog hosting.